San Francisco Light Rail Accident Investigation Raises Concern about Operators Disengaging Automatic Braking Systems
National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigators announced on April 28 that the operator of a San Francisco light rail involved in a 2009 accident blacked out and lost consciousness right after disengaging the train's automatic braking system. According to a San Francisco Chronicle article, the light rail ended up crashing and injuring several passengers as a result of the automatic brake controls being switched off.
The NTSB determined that the San Francisco Municipal Railway Transit System partially caused the San Francisco train accident by failing to enforce a regulation against turning off the controls before trains got to the station platform.
The Muni train was going over 20 mph when it hit a train that was immobile in the West Portal station. Based on the accident report, the Muni driver manually moved the train to the platform. When he lost consciousness, the train collided into the back of the second train already stopped at the platform. As a consequence of the crash, the operators of both trains and 46 passengers were injured.
This accident has raised concern about how Muni drivers regularly do not seek authorization to disengage the braking control before arriving at the West Portal. Apparently, drivers have said doing this makes it easier to bring the train to the platform. However, since the accident, Muni drivers have been warned that not asking permission to cut out the automatic brakes could make them lose their jobs. According to a Muni spokesman, the amount of times that drivers have disabled the braking system has dropped from 2,000 times per month before the accident to approximately eight times per month since the accident.
City municipalities can be held legally responsible for train accidents caused either completely or partially by the failure to implement and manage safety regulations. San Francisco accident lawyers understand the physical, financial, and psychological challenges accident victims face and are dedicated to holding negligent parties liable.